Freight volume barely moved in the third quarter, yet shippers paid more to haul them. According to the U.S. Bank Freight Payment Index, the truck freight market was shaped by three trends: tightening capacity putting upward pressure on rates, higher diesel prices driving up shipper costs, and uneven freight volume.
National shipments rose just 0.4% from Q2 and 0.5% from a year earlier in the third quarter. Spending climbed 5.2% from the previous quarter and 32.1% from the prior year, the strongest annual gain since 2021.
The report attributed the squeeze to tighter capacity. Federal and state officials have stepped up enforcement of driver rules and regulations, and carriers aren’t adding capacity. Spot rates averaged $3.11 per mile, up 43.3% year over year, while contract rates reached $3.25 per mile, up 26.8%.
Diesel also added to the pressure, hitting $6.53 per gallon on Sept. 21.
Large carriers’ third-quarter earnings calls suggest that attracting and retaining qualified drivers is becoming increasingly costly.
“Driver-related costs include recruiting, onboarding, training, sign-on bonuses and targeted wage actions,” said Brad Delco, EVP of finance and CFO, J.B. Hunt Transport Services (CCJ Top 250, No. 5) on a call with analysts.
Together, he said, the driver, claims and fuel buckets cut operating income by more than $50 million from the second quarter, and group medical costs alone accounted for over $16 million of that.
Werner Enterprises (No. 14) CEO Derek Leathers credited the company’s Roadmaster driving schools with helping it seat drivers where it needs them, but the pipeline is shrinking. Leathers said on the company’s earnings call that enrollments at Werner’s schools and others across the country are down 20% to 30% on average this year.
“That’s an ongoing battle to get people kind of interested in professional driving as an occupation,” he said.
Leathers added that nationwide audits of driver training schools are becoming more frequent, with Werners Roadmaster schools and Tier 1 partners passing inspections. “We’re working with the right people to trying to do it the right way, but that limits the pool of drivers you can pull from,” he said.
Pay alone won’t fix it too. Schneider National (No. 6) President and CEO Jim Filter said the company is tying driver pay increases to rate recovery.
“We’re not just throwing money at everything,” Filter said. “You just don’t solve this by money alone.” He said driver experience matters just as much, including freight selection, work configuration, how drivers are treated and how AI is used to respond to them faster.
Regional pressure points
The U.S. Bank Index’s regional data shows where the capacity squeeze is hitting the most. Spending rose in every region, even when volumes fell. The Southwest saw the biggest jump, with spending up 51.6% year over year while shipments were down 2.6%. The report said stronger enforcement of cross-border trucking requirements may be tightening capacity there, though it noted the impact can’t be confirmed without data on drivers denied entry.
The West saw shipments fall 3.1% from Q2 but spending rise 31.1% year over year, with California diesel reaching $8.25 per gallon in September. The Southeast posted the strongest quarterly shipment gain at 4.7%, with spending up 32.7% from a year earlier.








